BACKYARD NY / LOCAL-LAW REGISTRY
LOCAL LAW
✓Resolved — now regulated

Livingston BESS Local Laws

A rural Columbia County town with no battery proposal on record paused under a three-month moratorium in January 2024, extended it three times, then adopted a tiered permitting law that permits BESS — the moratorium ended by regulation, not prohibition.

Jurisdiction
TOWN OF LIVINGSTON · COLUMBIA COUNTY · HUDSON VALLEY
Restriction
PERMITTING REGULATION · RESOLVED — REGULATED
Current scope
≥30 KWH (EXCL. RESIDENTIAL)
Triggered by
NO PROJECT (PRECAUTIONARY)
Source confidence
MEDIUM-HIGHmedium-high — the full filing texts of Local Law 4 of 2024, Local Law 5 of 2024 (12-month, all-BESS) and Local Law 6 of 2025 (the tiered permitting law that permits BESS, Tier 1 ≤30 kWh residential by-right) were read directly, as were the 2024–2025 town board minutes; Local Law 6's filing certifies passage on August 14, 2025, and the June 2025 minutes record the 5–0 vote on Local Law 5 of 2025. The chain is one law longer than first recorded: Local Law 4 of 2024 is itself titled 'to extend a temporary three (3) month moratorium', and its recitals name an EARLIER original — a three-month moratorium adopted January 11, 2024 and expiring April 11, 2024. That original's own enacted text is not posted and the town's drafting is internally inconsistent about its number (§2 says Local Law #2 of 2024; §4A says Local Law #1 of 2024), so it is recorded at located-unconfirmed with the conflict left open rather than resolved by guess.

Background

Town of Livingston · Columbia County · Permitting regulation (moratorium lifted by regulation) · No in-town project

A restriction without a project

No battery storage project has been proposed in Livingston. The town acted because its comprehensive plan never contemplated BESS: the Supervisor noted only that some landowners had received letters of interest, and that the town was monitoring activity in nearby towns. (June 2025 minutes)

The chain began with a three-month moratorium adopted January 11, 2024, which its first extension records as set to expire that April; the enacted text of that original is not posted, and the town's own drafting numbers it inconsistently. A three-month extension followed (Local Law 4 of 2024, titled "to extend a temporary three (3) month moratorium," commencing April 11, 2024 with the stated intent of "no gap or lapse"). The board then adopted Local Law 5 of 2024, a twelve-month moratorium on all battery energy storage systems that adopts and extends Local Law 4. Its legislative intent grounds the pause in home rule — BESS "are not uses that were contemplated" in the comprehensive plan — alongside regulatory-uncertainty and "potential dangers such as fires" and other community impacts. (Local Law 5 of 2024)

The town then approved Local Law 5 of 2025, a three-month moratorium, 5–0 on June 12, 2025 after opening and closing a public hearing the same evening. The minutes call it "a local law adopting a three (3) month moratorium" rather than an extension, and they record no stated purpose for it — the Supervisor "gave an overview of the law," which the minutes do not summarise. (June 2025 minutes) On August 14, 2025, the board adopted Local Law 6 of 2025 — also 5–0 — a tiered permitting law that permits BESS: Tier 1 systems (≤30 kWh) are allowed by-right, and Tier 2 systems (>30 kWh) require a special use permit in the C-1 district. (Local Law 6 of 2025; August 2025 minutes)

Note that the statewide tracker labels Livingston "utility-scale," but the moratorium's own definition covered all BESS regardless of size — a scope correction that recurs across the Columbia County towns. The successor permitting law replaces that blanket scope with a 30 kWh tier split.

The instrument chain

  1. Moratorium Local Law 2 of 2024 2024-01-11 → 2024-04-11 located-unconfirmed
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: three months; per Local Law 4's recital, 'said moratorium is set to expire on April 11, 2024'
    • Regulatory uncertainty Recited in the extension as a three-month moratorium enacted while the town reviewed possible BESS regulations; the original law's own text was not located [source]
    [law text — located, portal-gated]
  2. Extension Local Law 4 of 2024 2024-04 → 2024-07-11
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: earlier of three months from the effective date (unless renewed) OR a board resolution that the need no longer exists
    • Local control §2 enacts the pause 'pursuant to its authority to adopt local laws under Article IX of the New York State Constitution and Municipal Home Rule Law Section 10', to allow study of 'Battery Energy Storage Systems and the current zoning law as it applies to the use within the town'; §4C applies it 'to all zoning districts and all real property within the Town' [source]
    • Regulatory uncertainty Adopted to 'extend the moratorium on Battery Energy Storage Systems until a revised law is adopted', with the stated intent 'to have no gap or lapse of said moratorium' [source]
    [law text]
  3. Extension Local Law 5 of 2024 2024-09 → 2025-09
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: earlier of 12 months OR adoption of BESS regulations / board resolution that the need has ended
    • Local control Adopts and extends Local Law 4 of 2024; BESS 'are not uses that were contemplated' in the comprehensive plan, and the town defends home rule against the 'public utility' theory of state preemption [source]
    • Regulatory uncertainty §2 records the town 'is currently reviewing possible regulations for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) and desires to draft a zoning law amendment that would provide for proper regulation of such projects and installations', and that 'the extension of the moratorium will enable town officials to comprehensively address the issues involved with BESS' [source]
    • Fire safety Legislative intent cites 'potential dangers such as fires' alongside environmental, visual, and community impacts [source]
    [law text]
  4. Moratorium Local Law 5 of 2025 2025-06-12 → 2025-09
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: three months from adoption
    • Regulatory uncertainty The June 12, 2025 minutes record Resolution #77, a 'Motion to approve Local Law #5 of 2025, a local law adopting a three (3) month moratorium on Battery Energy Storage Systems', carried 'Votes 5 Ayes, 0 no'; the same meeting set a hearing on 'Local Law #6 of 2025, a local law addressing Battery Energy Storage Systems' — the permitting law that followed. The minutes state no drafting rationale; asked what prompted it, the Supervisor said interest 'has been around for about a year and a half here and within other towns in Columbia County and some land owners have received letters of interest' [source]
    [law text]
  5. Permitting regulation Local Law 6 of 2025 2025-08-14
    Scope — ≥30 kWh (excl. residential)
    • Land use §A states the law is 'enacted to promote and protect the public health, safety, welfare, and quality of life for the residents of the Town of Livingston', establishing a regulatory framework whose objectives include 'to ensure land use compatibility between battery energy storage systems and surrounding uses' and 'to minimize potential impacts on environmental resources, including prime agricultural lands, forests, wildlife habitats, and other protected natural features' [source]
    • Regulatory uncertainty The tiering is express: Tier 1 systems are 'for residential use only' with 'an aggregate energy capacity less than or equal to 30 kWh' and are 'permitted in all zoning districts … and exempt from site plan review'; Tier 2 systems (over 30 kWh) are 'permitted through the issuance of a special use permit within C-1 (Commercial Zone)'. The Schedule of Permitted Uses marks Tier 1 'P' in all eight districts and Tier 2 permitted only in C-1 [source]
    [law text]
Fire service∅None stated[Town of Livingston]

For it

  • Town of Livingston Town Board — adopted a three-month BESS moratorium in January 2024, extended it three months in Local Law 4 of 2024, then twelve months in Local Law 5 of 2024, on all battery energy storage systems while drafting zoning [Town of Livingston]
    Official ⊙ Wants review
  • Town of Livingston Town Board — approved Local Law 5 of 2025, a three-month BESS moratorium, 5–0 on June 12, 2025, at a meeting whose public hearing was opened and closed the same evening [Town of Livingston]
    Official ⊙ Wants review

Against it

  • No BESS developer or local opponent of the restriction surfaced in the public record; every instrument in the chain was adopted 5–0

Analysis

Livingston is the good-faith end of the moratorium spectrum. A small rural town with no application before it paused, wrote rules, and now permits battery storage under a tiered local law — the moratorium ended by regulation, not prohibition. Two of the instruments in the chain are on record as passing 5–0 — Local Law 5 of 2025 and Local Law 6 of 2025; the earlier ones carry no vote on any document read here. The permitting law's purpose clause ties its terms to "prime agricultural lands, forests, wildlife habitats, and other protected natural features" and to "the broader goals and policies outlined in the Town Code and the community's comprehensive planning efforts" while still accommodating BESS rather than excluding it. That trajectory distinguishes Livingston from neighboring Claverack and Stockport, whose moratoria remain active, and from Montgomery and Plattekill, which ended in permanent bans.

Enabling authority

Town Law §§261-263 · Municipal Home Rule Law §10

Sources

// every field traceable to a primary source · outcome classified per documented record · BACKYARD NY