Methodology
Backyard NY documents Hudson Valley development and infrastructure projects —
primarily battery energy storage (BESS) — and what happens to them. This page
explains how each project is classified and sourced, so the labels on every
detail page mean the same thing from one case to the next.
Sourcing & neutrality
The site aims to read even-handed; the point of view lives in what is
documented and how carefully, not in editorializing. Opposing
values and positions are presented with equal weight; factual claims are
weighed by the strength of the evidence behind them (see
How we weigh evidence, below).
- Every claim is cited. Each supporter and opponent carries a source link; an entry with no source is shown only as an explicitly-marked absence.
- Actors only in "For it" / "Against it." Those lists hold people, bodies, companies, and organized groups that have taken a position — never a policy or target (see Context, below).
- Primary sources preferred. Official records — board resolutions, filings, agency documents — outrank secondary coverage. Industry-funded sources are cited narrowly, for specific facts, never for framing.
How we weigh evidence
Even-handed does not mean treating every claim as a coin-flip. The site weighs
factual claims by the strength of the evidence behind them — not by how many people
are on each side — and it keeps three different kinds of claim apart:
- Established fact Where there is genuine scientific or expert consensus — that the climate is
warming, or the basic physics of how the grid balances supply and demand — the site
states it plainly and cites the authoritative source, rather than staging a debate.
Counting voices is not the same as weighing evidence.
- Genuinely contested Where experts actually disagree or the data is still developing — such as the
precise fire risk of a particular battery chemistry — the site presents the
disagreement and describes how strong the evidence is on each side.
- Values & judgment Where the question is one of values — whether a grid benefit justifies a local
risk, or how to weigh a state mandate against local control — the site lays out both
sides fairly and leaves the judgment to you. This is where equal weight genuinely
applies.
This is why the site can state the climate and grid backdrop as established fact while
still presenting both sides of a specific project: they are different kinds of
question. Stating the backdrop never prejudges whether a particular battery belongs in
a particular place — that siting question turns on values and local judgment, and the
site does not decide it for you. One guardrail throughout: a person's values are always
respected, but the factual claims offered in support of them are checked on their own
merits.
How this site is researched
This site's research is performed by AI agents. Software agents locate
and read the underlying records — adopted local laws, town board minutes, agency filings,
news coverage — and draft the summaries and structured data behind every page. A human
editor directs that work, decides what gets documented,
and approves what publishes. Saying so plainly is part of the point: a reader deserves to
know how the thing in front of them was made, and to weigh it accordingly.
The division of labor is deliberate:
- The agents gather and quote. They are pointed at primary records first — a town's own filed law text rather than a news summary of it — and asked to return exact citations and verbatim language, not conclusions.
- Gathering is separated from writing. The agent that searches and reads records cannot write to this site. It returns citations and verbatim quotes; a separate editor-directed pass re-reads the cited document against the claim — a law's number, its term, what it actually prohibits — and builds the page from that. No page stands on the authority of the agent that found the material. What this does not provide is an independent checker: the pass that verifies a claim is the same pass that writes it up. That is a real limit, and this page previously described the separation as stronger than it is.
- A human directs and is accountable. The editor sets the framing, approves what publishes, and answers for it.
Several constraints are built into the site rather than left to good intentions:
- Every claim carries a source link, and the build refuses to publish a named supporter or opponent without one. An unsourced absence is shown as an explicit absence.
- Sources are classified by independence. A registry rates every cited outlet — government primary, academic, independent local press, industry trade, advocacy. An advocacy group or a company is citable for its own stated position, never as the record for someone else's.
- The research agent cannot publish. It has no ability to write to this site; it returns findings that a person has to act on. That is a structural limit, not a policy.
- Citations are re-checked automatically. Every source link is re-fetched whenever the site's content changes, and dead links are reported — a citation that no longer resolves is a claim that can no longer be verified. The limit is worth stating plainly: a number of sources, including some government sites and some paywalled papers, refuse automated requests outright. Those are flagged as such and can only be checked by hand.
- Whether we opened the document is recorded on the page. Where a source has been read in full, its entry says so. Where it was only located — behind a paywall, a block, or as a scan that could not be read — it says that instead, because the difference matters and burying it would be the easier thing to do. Most sources on the site are not yet marked either way; that work is in progress and the unmarked ones are simply unmarked, not verified.
- Confidence is published, not implied. Each page states how well-sourced it is, and open questions are listed as open rather than smoothed over.
What this does not guarantee
The controls above establish that a claim is sourced — that a citation exists, resolves,
and is properly attached to what it supports. They do not establish that the
source says what the page says it says. That is the real limit of this method: a
citation can be present, well-formed, resolvable, and still not support the claim built on
it, and no automated check will catch that. Only reading the underlying document will.
That reading is directed by this site's editor and performed by the same pass that writes
the pages — a careful re-reading, not an independent audit. So the machinery narrows the
ways this can go wrong; it does not close them, and it is not a substitute for the record.
Where a page matters to you, follow its sources.
There is a limit on coverage, too, not only on claims. Much local argument
happens in neighborhood Facebook groups, on Nextdoor and on Reddit. This site does not cover
it. Organized groups and petitions are cited for their own stated positions; individual posts
are not, because they cannot be re-checked later, and because posting in a neighborhood group
is not the same as speaking on the record at a public meeting. Where a project's opposition
looks thin here, that may reflect where we looked.
Corrections
If you are named on this site, or you know a record here is wrong, please tell
us. Corrections are welcome from anyone — a town clerk with the filed law, a
developer with the actual capacity, a resident who was in the room.
- Email: support@undaunteddigital.com
- Point to the page and, where you can, the record that shows the correction. A document, a resolution number, or a meeting date is the fastest possible route to a fix.
- Substantive corrections are made promptly and noted on the page, so the change is visible rather than silent. Disagreements about interpretation — whether a project's benefits justify its local costs — are not corrections; those are the arguments the site exists to document, and it will keep presenting both sides with their sources.
- Missed something? tips@undaunteddigital.com — if a project or local law in the Hudson Valley isn't here, tell us. The record is assembled from town minutes, filed laws and local reporting, so a proposal that hasn't reached those yet can be invisible to it. A tip is a lead, not a source: nothing arrives on this site because someone wrote in. We go and read the record, and if we can't establish it from a document, it doesn't get published.
Outcome
The honest scorecard — where a project actually ended up:
- ✓Delivered Built and operating, or fully approved and under construction toward operation.
- ✓Delivered (shrunk) Built or approved, but materially smaller than originally proposed.
- ◐In progress Actively moving through review or permitting; the outcome is not yet decided (often contested).
- ⏸Stalled Paused or obstructed without a final decision — under a moratorium, in litigation, or dormant.
- ✕Killed Formally rejected, banned, or withdrawn with no current path forward.
Source confidence
How well-sourced a case's facts are (labeled Source confidence on
the detail page, with the specifics in a tooltip). The meter fills from one to four
segments:
- HIGH Every material fact — capacity, site, ownership, official actions, named positions — is confirmed against a primary source (a government record or official filing) or corroborated by multiple independent reports. Nothing material outstanding.
- MEDIUM-HIGH The core facts are sourced to credible local or trade press and/or a primary record, with one or two secondary details still to confirm against primary sources.
- MEDIUM The narrative is supported by press reporting, but key specifics (exact dates, vote text, capacity) still need primary-source confirmation.
- LOW Early or thinly sourced — a single report or preliminary information. Treat as provisional.
Process
The legal or procedural lever(s) that shaped the outcome (labeled
Process on the detail page; each value has a tooltip). The
controlled vocabulary:
- SEQRA State Environmental Quality Review Act — New York's environmental review process. A "positive declaration" triggers a full Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) before any approval.
- ARTICLE 78 Article 78 — a New York court proceeding used to challenge a government body's decision or approval.
- LOCAL ZONING Local zoning — town/village land-use rules and special-use permits. Standalone battery storage is sited locally under home rule.
- MORATORIUM BAN A local pause (moratorium) on new projects while rules are studied — or an outright ban.
- PILOT IDA PILOT / IDA — a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes agreement granted through an Industrial Development Agency.
- REFERENDUM Referendum — a public vote on the project or a related local measure.
- FINANCING Financing — the project's funding, contract, or incentive status shaped the outcome.
- STATE OVERRIDE State override — siting decided or preempted at the state level (e.g. ORES under Executive Law §94-c) rather than by the town.
- WITHDRAWN Withdrawn — the developer pulled the proposal.
- OTHER Other mechanism — see the project narrative.
For it · Against it · Context
For it and Against it list the actors on each
side, with sources. Context is a separate, neutral strip for
backdrop that is not a position — statewide policy targets, market conditions —
so a policy is never miscast as a project's supporter or opponent.
Capacity
Battery projects are described by power (megawatts, MW — how much
it can deliver at once) and energy (megawatt-hours, MWh — how much
it stores). These are not the same number: a 250 MW / 1,000 MWh project is
a 4-hour battery (energy ÷ power = duration). Power, energy, and duration are
the measures used by the U.S. Energy Information Administration and the national labs,
so they are what this site reports. There is no single industry standard for labeling a
project "small," "medium," or "large," so the site does not yet assign size bands; that
convention is still being worked out.
Why no "homes served" figure. Developer and press materials often
describe a battery as enough to "power N homes." The site does not adopt that
number, because no government body, national lab, or standards organization publishes a
rigorous way to convert storage capacity into homes served. The familiar
"homes powered" gloss is a generation approximation — annual energy output
divided by an average household's yearly use — and even there agencies treat it as a
rough estimate that swings widely by region. A battery generates no annual energy: it
shifts a fixed amount of stored energy and discharges it for a limited duration, then
must recharge. An unqualified "powers N homes" therefore misrepresents storage
as if it were a power plant. Where such a claim is relevant, it is reported as the
explicit statement of whoever made it — not as a site-asserted fact — alongside the
MW / MWh / duration that can actually be sourced.
Freshness
These are live fights. Where a fact can change, the case carries an "as of" date so
its age is visible. A status with an old date may simply not have changed — or may
need re-checking.
A living document
Cases are maintained on an ongoing basis, including with agent-assisted research.
This methodology is the shared rulebook that keeps that work consistent over time.