BACKYARD NY / LOCAL-LAW REGISTRY
LOCAL LAW
?Lapsed (unconfirmed)

Claverack BESS Moratorium

A Columbia County town that fielded developer interest but no formal application has paused battery storage twice — a 2024 chain of three short laws that ran a year and expired, then a fresh moratorium adopted in December 2025 that the board moved to extend in February 2026 — while it writes regulations.

Jurisdiction
TOWN OF CLAVERACK · COLUMBIA COUNTY · HUDSON VALLEY
Restriction
MORATORIUM · MORATORIUM — LAPSED?
Current scope
ALL BESS
Triggered by
NO PROJECT (PRECAUTIONARY)
Source confidence
MEDIUMmedium — the three 2024 law texts are primary, retrieved from the town's Codes & Laws page after its site migration (townofclaverack.com → claverackny.gov); all three are posted under 'Draft LL…' labels and the Local Law 2 of 2024 copy carries a DRAFT watermark, and none of the retrieved pages carries an adoption or effective date, so the chain's dates are unconfirmed. All three define a battery storage system as essentially any rechargeable system (excluding only a stand-alone 12-volt car battery or an electric motor vehicle) applying to all zoning districts — so the scope is ALL BESS, correcting the Carina tracker's 'utility-scale' label. The December 2025 moratorium rests on secondary reporting only: the Daily Gazette reports the board passed a three-month moratorium on Dec 11, 2025 and scheduled a Feb 12, 2026 public hearing on extending it to six months, but names no law number, and no 2025–26 BESS law is posted on the town's Codes & Laws page. Whether the six-month extension was adopted, and what has happened since it would have run out, is unconfirmed.

Background

Town of Claverack · Columbia County · Moratorium (lapsed, unconfirmed) · No in-town project

A restriction without a project

No battery storage project has been formally proposed in Claverack. The town's own law text records that it "has been approached by a developer with an interest in installing a BESS system" who argued the use was entitled to a "public utility" theory of zoning — a theory the town noted is "used to override the local home rule power." Reporting adds that two unnamed companies inquired about building storage before the town's December 2025 action. (The Daily Gazette)

Claverack has paused battery storage twice, in two separate chains. The first ran through 2024: an original three-month moratorium (Local Law 2 of 2024), a three-month extension (Local Law 4 of 2024), then a twelve-month extension (Local Law 6 of 2024) adopted with the stated intent that there be "no lapse or gap." That chain then ran out.

On December 11, 2025 the board adopted a fresh three-month moratorium — what Town Attorney Robert Fitzsimmons called "a second moratorium" — and in February 2026 scheduled a public hearing on extending the pause to six months total. Because Columbia County exempts land-use moratoria of three months or less from General Municipal Law §239-m referral, the longer term required the county planning board's review; Fitzsimmons said doing it in three-month increments was "just too much process." He also said the board might need to extend again: "It's to be determined." (The Daily Gazette)

Every Claverack instrument reaches all BESS in every district — each defines a battery storage system as essentially any rechargeable system, excluding only a stand-alone 12-volt car battery or an electric motor vehicle — not just utility-scale projects as a third-party tracker had labeled it. The written legislative intent rests on regulatory uncertainty, local control, and land use: BESS "are not uses that were contemplated within the town's comprehensive plan, or current zoning law." Fire-safety concerns appear in board discussion and reporting, but not as any law's stated purpose.

The instrument chain

  1. Moratorium Local Law 2 of 2024 located-unconfirmed
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: earlier of three months from the effective date (unless renewed) OR a board resolution that the need has ended
    • Regulatory uncertainty Legislative intent: the town is 'reviewing possible regulations' for BESS and 'desires to draft a zoning law amendment' before any system is built [source]
    • Local control The board reserves siting decisions pending its own zoning amendment, to ensure systems 'are placed and sited in harmony with the surrounding uses and areas of the town' [source]
    [law text — located, portal-gated]
  2. Extension Local Law 4 of 2024
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: a further three months; earlier of three months from the effective date (unless renewed) OR a board resolution that the need has ended
    • Regulatory uncertainty Adopted 'to further review a revised law that may be adopted'; kept the moratorium running while the town continued drafting [source]
    [law text]
  3. Extension Local Law 6 of 2024
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: earlier of twelve months from the effective date (unless renewed) OR enactment of BESS zoning regulations / a board resolution that the need has ended
    • Regulatory uncertainty Twelve-month extension; the town had 'recently engaged a consultant to gain additional unbiased information on BESS' and needed time to study the use and adopt zoning regulations [source]
    • Local control States the town was approached by a developer asserting BESS is entitled to a 'public utility' theory of zoning — a theory 'used to override the local home rule power of the town' [source]
    • Land use BESS installations 'are not uses that were contemplated within the town's comprehensive plan, or current zoning law' [source]
    [law text]
  4. Moratorium 2025-12-11 secondary
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: three months from adoption; the board moved in February 2026 to extend the pause to six months total
    • Regulatory uncertainty Town Attorney: the reason is to give board members time to gather information and 'come up with regulations for the storage systems that are appropriate for the town'; members were consulting NYSERDA and the Pace University Land Use Law Center, and the matter was referred to the Comprehensive Plan Committee [source]
    • Fire safety Town Attorney: 'There's been concerns about fires, and things like that, and obviously the local necessity for them' — raised in board discussion, per reporting [source]
    [law text — secondary]
Fire service∅None stated[The Daily Gazette / HudsonValley360]

For it

  • Town of Claverack Town Board — adopted an all-BESS moratorium and kept extending it (Local Law 2 of 2024, a three-month extension in Local Law 4 of 2024, then a twelve-month extension in Local Law 6 of 2024), and after that chain ran out adopted a fresh three-month moratorium on Dec 11, 2025 while it drafts regulations [Town of Claverack]
    Official ⊙ Wants review
  • Robert Fitzsimmons, Town Attorney — said the town wants to [The Daily Gazette / HudsonValley360]
    Official ⊙ Wants review
    evaluate them, just like they did with solar fields, and come up with good regulations for them before they are built

Against it

Analysis

Claverack shows the same precautionary posture as Livingston and Stockport — regulate before anyone builds — but with a twist the stage chain makes visible: the pause lapsed and was re-enacted rather than running continuously, and after roughly two years of moratoria the town still has no BESS regulation on the books. What the record does show is a town doing the study work it said the pause was for: engaging a consultant, drawing on NYSERDA's model law and the Pace University Land Use Law Center, and referring the question to its Comprehensive Plan Committee.

The site's confidence here is medium, and the reason is worth stating plainly. The 2024 texts are primary but are posted as undated, draft-labeled filing forms. The December 2025 moratorium rests entirely on one local newspaper report, which names no law number — and no 2025–26 BESS law appears on the town's own Codes & Laws index. Whether the six-month extension passed, and what has happened since it would have expired, is not established on the public record.

Enabling authority

NYS Constitution Art. IX §2 · Statute of Local Governments Art. II §10 · Town Law §§261-263 · Municipal Home Rule Law §10 · General Municipal Law §239-m (county planning referral; moratoria of three months or less exempt by the town's 'Opt Out' resolution)

Sources

// every field traceable to a primary source · outcome classified per documented record · BACKYARD NY