BACKYARD NY / LOCAL-LAW REGISTRY
LOCAL LAW
✕Permanent ban

Plattekill BESS Ban

Plattekill paused large-scale battery storage with a six-month moratorium, extended it, then converted the pause into a permanent zoning ban on large-scale BESS — keeping a carve-out for modest residential systems.

Jurisdiction
TOWN OF PLATTEKILL · ULSTER COUNTY · HUDSON VALLEY
Restriction
PERMANENT BAN · BANNED — PERMANENT
Current scope
UTILITY-SCALE (EXCL. RESIDENTIAL)
Triggered by
Source confidence
MEDIUMmedium — the moratorium (Local Law 3 of 2024, Resolution #65, 4-0, with a Nov 20, 2024 hearing) is from the town's own notice; the extension, the permanent ban, the large-scale-only scope with a residential carve-out, the rationale, and the Mission Clear project details are from bylined, contemporaneous local-newspaper coverage (consistent across articles). The permanent-ban local-law number and exact adoption date are not in any accessible primary source (eCode360 returns 403). A 2026-07-24 claim audit re-read every cited article: the project figures (~300 MW, ~40 of a ~95-acre parcel, Camp Sunset/Rabbit Run, conceptual only), the unanimous large-scale ban, the residential carve-out and the withdrawal all check out verbatim — but two claims had been attached to the wrong article and are now re-cited or withdrawn (the project name 'Chalkstone' appears in NO cited source and is an open watch item).

Background

Town of Plattekill · Ulster County · Permanent zoning ban (large-scale BESS)

A pause that became a prohibition

Plattekill's restriction grew out of a single in-town proposal: roughly 300 MW on about 40 of a ~95-acre parcel at Camp Sunset Road and Rabbit Run Road, advanced by a developer the town referred to as Mission Clear Energy. It was only ever presented conceptually to the Planning Board, with no formal application submitted, and the company has since "pulled their project". (Times Hudson Valley) The project's record as a project is documented separately in the Mission Clear Energy BESS case.

The Town Board moved in stages:

  1. Moratorium (Local Law 3 of 2024): Resolution #65 (adopted 4-0 on October 16, 2024) set a public hearing for November 20, 2024, after which the board adopted a six-month moratorium on large-scale battery storage while it studied the issue. (Town of Plattekill notice)
  2. Extension (~June 2025): the board extended the moratorium for another six months. (Times Hudson Valley)
  3. Permanent ban (fall 2025): the board voted unanimously to prohibit large-scale BESS town-wide, citing the potential for hard-to-extinguish lithium-ion fires that release toxic gases, impacts to "human health, safety and the environment," and a desire to act ahead of new state rules. (Times Hudson Valley)

The ban targets large-scale storage; it allows residents to have a modest battery system at their homes, so it is not an all-BESS prohibition. (Times Hudson Valley) County-level Republicans — Legislators Brian Roberts, Craig Lopez and Eric Stewart — amplified the effort, framing it as keeping local control and arguing "Ulster County should not be a testing ground." Supervisor Dean DePew Sr. and Councilman James Fazio backed the town's prohibition. (Times Hudson Valley)

The instrument chain

  1. Moratorium Local Law 3 of 2024 → 2025-06 located-unconfirmed
    Scope — All BESS · sunset: six months (per the introduced law's title as recited in Resolution #65; the enacted text has never been located)
    • Fire safety Residents and officials cited the potential for lithium-ion fires that are difficult to extinguish and release toxic gases [source]
    • Regulatory uncertainty Board sought time to study the issue and await new state battery-storage rules expected later that year [source]
    [law text — located, portal-gated]
  2. Extension 2025-06 → 2025-12 secondary
    • Regulatory uncertainty Board extended the moratorium another six months while it continued to study large-scale storage [source]
    [law text — secondary]
  3. Permanent ban 2025 located-unconfirmed
    Scope — Utility-scale (excl. residential)
    • Fire safety Cited the potential of fires that are difficult to extinguish and that release toxic gases [source]
    • Land use Cited impacts to human health, safety and the environment [source]
    • Regulatory uncertainty Acted ahead of new state battery-storage rules expected in October [source]
    • Local control County Republicans framed the ban as keeping control of local siting — 'Ulster County should not be a testing ground' [source]
    [law text — located, portal-gated]
Fire service∅None stated[Southern Ulster Times / Times Hudson Valley]

For it

Against it

Analysis

The safety concerns the board cited are concrete: lithium-ion fires are difficult to extinguish, and the Warwick BESS fire is a nearby reference point. The question Plattekill raises is one of regulatory approach — whether large-scale storage is governed by setback rules, fire codes, and siting standards applied to specific proposals, or by a town-wide prohibition adopted after the only proposal had withdrawn. By preserving a carve-out for modest home batteries, the law distinguishes residential storage from utility-scale siting rather than barring the technology outright. The same moratorium-to-permanent-ban trajectory appears in Montgomery, while neighboring Hurley is moving along the same path. Each such decision feeds the cumulative outcome on which New York's 6 GW storage target depends.

Enabling authority

NYS Constitution Art. IX §2 · Town Law §§261-263 · Municipal Home Rule Law §10

Sources

// every field traceable to a primary source · outcome classified per documented record · BACKYARD NY