BACKYARD NY / LOCAL-LAW REGISTRY
LOCAL LAW
✕Permanent ban

Montgomery BESS Zoning Ban

Montgomery escalated a one-year moratorium into a permanent zoning prohibition on battery storage — codified as a prohibited use in Chapter 235 — mooting an advanced 169 MW project.

Jurisdiction
TOWN OF MONTGOMERY · ORANGE COUNTY · HUDSON VALLEY
Restriction
PERMANENT BAN · BANNED — PERMANENT
Current scope
ALL BESS (EXCL. RESIDENTIAL)
Triggered by
Source confidence
MEDIUM-HIGHmedium-high — the 2023 moratorium (Local Law 6 of 2023, adopted 5-0 on Nov 28 2023) and the triggering project (KCE NY 2 — 169 MW/300 MWh, executed LGIA, NYISO Queue #683, PSC Case 22-E-0488) are primary-sourced (town minutes; PSC docket). The 2025 ban was read from the codified chapter for the first time on 2026-07-28, and three things this file asserted did not survive it. (1) The law number was wrong: the chapter attributes the prohibition to L.L. No. 2-2025, while L.L. No. 3-2025 is a 3-5-2025 law amending the definitions section and creating a Business Park Floating Zone. (2) The claim that the ban is 'not an amendment to §235-11.13' is refuted — the same L.L. No. 2-2025 REPEALED §235-11.13, which now reads '(Reserved)'; the 2022 baseline attribution to Local Law 4 of 2022 is confirmed. (3) The effective date Mar 5 2025 was L.L. No. 3-2025's date carried onto this law; the chapter states no effective date for the prohibition, so the field is now omitted. The operative provision is §235-9.1I, 'Prohibited uses enumerated', reaching BESS 'in all districts' except those authorized by 2020 NYS Residential Code §1206 for one- and two-family homes. Still unread: the filed L.L. No. 2-2025 text (eCode360 legref LF2295683, 403, no Wayback snapshot) and Attachment 1, the Table of Use Regulations (403, no snapshot), so a parallel Use-Table amendment can be neither confirmed nor excluded. The codification is current through 03-05-2025 with a new-laws scan of 2025-10-30, so it cannot speak to anything adopted after that.

Background

Town of Montgomery · Orange County · Permanent zoning ban · In-town project (mooted)

A moratorium hardened into a ban

The Town of Montgomery moved in two steps. On November 28, 2023, the Town Board adopted Local Law 6 of 2023, a 12-month moratorium on battery storage — passed 5-0, exempting only 1-2 family residential storage compliant with §1206 of the 2020 NYS Residential Code. The board cited fire risk (referencing the Warwick BESS fires, and that such fires "burn out" rather than being put out), first-responder readiness, and a desire to wait on Governor Hochul's statewide BESS safety study. (Town minutes)

The pause then became permanent. After a public hearing on February 19, 2025, the board voted at a February 25, 2025 special meeting to amend its zoning. (Wallkill Valley Times) In the codified zoning chapter the prohibition sits in § 235-9.1, "Prohibited uses enumerated," carrying the history note "[Amended 2-25-2025 by L.L. No. 2-2025]". Its subsection I bars "Battery Energy Storage Systems other than those authorized by the 2020 New York State Residential Code Section 1206 for one- and two-family homes," and the section's lead-in applies it "[i]n all districts." The same law repealed § 235-11.13, the town's 2022 battery-storage regulation added by Local Law 4 of 2022; that section now reads "(Reserved)". (Chapter 235, Zoning)

So the exemption is narrower than "residential scale": it is keyed to one- and two-family homes under a specific code section. The chapter sets no kWh or MW threshold and defines "Battery Energy Storage System" nowhere — the definition presumably went with the repealed section.

(Corrected 2026-07-28, when this chapter was opened here for the first time. This page previously named the ban Local Law 3 of 2025, gave it an effective date of March 5, 2025, and stated that it was a Use-Table amendment and specifically not a change to § 235-11.13. The chapter contradicts all three: L.L. No. 3-2025 is a March 5 law amending the definitions section and creating a Business Park Floating Zone; the chapter states no effective date for the prohibition; and § 235-11.13 was repealed by this very law. The filed law text and the Table of Use Regulations attachment both still refuse every automated request, so whether the Use Table was amended in parallel remains open — see watch.)

The project it stopped

The restriction was prompted by an in-town filing. KCE NY 2, a 169 MW / 300 MWh project from Key Capture Energy, was a genuinely advanced proposal — an executed LGIA, NYISO Queue #683, and a petition on file at the Public Service Commission (Case 22-E-0488). (PSC petition) It was first stalled by the 2023 moratorium, then mooted by the 2025 ban; no separate withdrawal is on record.

Support and opposition

The 2023 moratorium passed 5-0 under Supervisor Ronald Feller, with Kristen Brown leading the push; Coldenham Fire District Chief Matthew Hunt submitted correspondence read into the record expressing concern for first-responder safety. (Town minutes) At the 2025 ban hearing, Key Capture Energy's Mike Carella pointed to "unprecedented load growth," two Cypress Creek Renewables developers warned a local ban could invite a state takeover of permitting and argued incidents are rare under national standards, and IBEW Local 363's Tom Knapp spoke for the jobs at stake. The board was unmoved: Supervisor Steve Brescia cited "too many unknowns" and a California incident that evacuated 1,200, and Councilwoman Sheryl Melick judged local fire departments unequipped. (Wallkill Valley Times)

The instrument chain

  1. Moratorium Local Law 6 of 2023 2023-11-28 → 2024-11
    Scope — All BESS (excl. residential) · sunset: 12 months from enactment; timed to Governor Hochul's statewide BESS safety study
    • Fire safety Councilwoman Brown said 'her main concern is the safety of the first responders showing up to these potential fires', that 'sometimes the fires require a one-mile radius "stay in place"', and that she 'had been told that the fires are not put out, rather they burn out' — asking 'are we going to give first responders the training they need?' She also read Coldenham Fire District Chief Matthew Hunt's correspondence into the record [source]
    • Local control The board weighed doubling the pause to twelve months for local readiness: Brown noted that 'when the Comprehensive Plan was done, the ramifications of battery storage facilities potentially catching on fire were not known', and Supervisor Feller 'stated he has no problem extending the moratorium to a year' [source]
    • Regulatory uncertainty Supervisor Feller told the hearing that 'Governor Hochul is conducting a 6-month study on the subject' and that 'if the study is not completed in 6 months, the moratorium could always be extended' — the timing rationale is his, stated in board discussion, not a finding in the law's text [source]
    • Land use Raised by a resident, not the board: Richard Phelps told the hearing the town's rewritten solar law 'lacked any controls on placing battery packs on the ridge lines of the Town' and that any new law 'should include that the ridge lines should also be protected from storage units - the same way they're protected from solar panels' [source]
    [law text]
  2. Permanent ban Local Law 2 of 2025 2025-02-25
    Scope — All BESS (excl. residential)
    • Fire safety Supervisor cited 'too many unknowns' and a California incident that evacuated 1,200; board judged local fire departments unequipped for these systems [source]
    • Local control The Wallkill Valley Times reports the board enacting the prohibition as a zoning amendment under Chapter 235, acting on the 2023 ban proposal. The codified text places it at § 235-9.1I, 'Prohibited uses enumerated', rather than in the Use Table [source]
    [law text]
Fire service◐Conditional[Town of Montgomery (eCode360)]

For it

  • Town Board (Nov 28, 2023) — adopted the 12-month moratorium 5-0; Supervisor Ronald Feller, with council members Cindy Voss, Kristen Brown (who led the moratorium push), Sheryl Melick, and Michael Setteducato [Town of Montgomery (eCode360)]
    Official ⊙ Wants review
  • Kristen Brown, then-Town Councilwoman — led the 2023 moratorium push and originated the ban proposal, citing battery-fire danger and strain on first responders [Town of Montgomery (eCode360)]
    Official ⚑ Opposes siting
  • Supervisor Steve Brescia (Feb 2025) — cited a California incident that evacuated 1,200 people; felt town and state fire response were not ready [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Official ⚑ Opposes siting
    too many unknowns,
  • Councilwoman Sheryl Melick (Feb 2025) — 'I don't believe our fire departments are up to code with them... I just think it's hazardous for the residents of the town' [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Official ⚑ Opposes siting
  • Coldenham Fire District Chief Matthew Hunt — submitted correspondence read into the November 28, 2023 record expressing concern for first-responder safety (the correspondence text itself does not appear in the minutes) [Town of Montgomery (eCode360)]
    Fire service ◐ Conditional

Against it

  • Mike Carella, Senior Manager of Development, Key Capture Energy — cited and more than a gigawatt of new load requests in the lower Hudson Valley [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Developer ⊕ Supports siting
    unprecedented load growth
  • Will O'Leary, Senior Project Developer, Cypress Creek Renewables — warned a local ban could push the state to bring battery-storage permitting under state control [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Business
  • Eva Raczkowski, Project Developer, Cypress Creek Renewables — argued incidents are rare and facilities are designed and monitored to strict national fire-safety standards [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Business ⊚ Supports, on safety review
  • Tom Knapp, IBEW Local 363 — spoke in favor of battery storage and the jobs it would bring [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Labor ⊕ Supports siting

Analysis

Montgomery is the clearest local example of the escalation a moratorium can become: a pause adopted to "buy time" while the state studied safety hardened into a permanent zoning prohibition, mooting an advanced 169 MW project. The developers' own warning — that local bans invite a state takeover of siting — is the ORES-for-storage argument stated from the industry side; at 169 MW KCE NY 2 would clear the 25 MW threshold that would put it under state siting, if standalone storage were ever brought into that forum. The same moratorium-to-permanent-ban trajectory appears in neighboring Chester and Plattekill. The recurring fault line is fire safety — a developer and a peer firm citing national standards and load growth, against a board, and a fire chief's correspondence, that judged local emergency services unready.

Enabling authority

Town Law §§261-263 · Municipal Home Rule Law §10

Sources

// every field traceable to a primary source · outcome classified per documented record · BACKYARD NY