A 169 MW battery proposal the Town of Montgomery blocked by escalating from a one-year moratorium to a permanent zoning ban on battery storage.
Town of Montgomery · Orange County · Energy storage · Status: killed (zoning ban)
KCE NY 2 was a 169-megawatt battery storage project from Key Capture Energy, proposed on an 8.03-acre site north of Route 17K between Stone Castle Road and Browns Road. It was aired at a Montgomery Industrial Development Agency public hearing in November 2022 and is recorded as "KCE NY 2, LLC" on the IDA's project page. (Wallkill Valley Times; Montgomery IDA) (A separate, earlier Key Capture project — KCE NY 11, a 20 MW battery also in the Town of Montgomery — received a NYSERDA energy-storage incentive; it is not the project at issue here. The company's announcement is explicit that a different project came first: "our KCE NY 1 project was the first project to be awarded under NYSERDA's energy storage incentive program." The announcement carries no date.) (Key Capture Energy)
The ban would block KCE NY 2; no separate withdrawal is on record, and the Montgomery IDA still carries the project as Pending. (Montgomery IDA)
The law's number, effective date and exact scope are not established by anything opened here — the eCode360 amendment history that would settle them refuses automated and browser-style requests alike. This page therefore states what the reporting establishes and no more; the open questions are recorded in the case's watch list.
At the February 2025 hearing, Key Capture Energy's Mike Carella pointed to "unprecedented load growth" in the lower Hudson Valley, and two Cypress Creek Renewables developers spoke — Will O'Leary warning that local bans could prompt the state to take over permitting, and Eva Raczkowski arguing incidents are rare under national fire-safety standards. The board was unmoved. Councilwoman Sheryl Melick said "there are too many unknowns about these battery storages, and I don't believe our fire departments are up to code with them." Supervisor Steve Brescia concurred, citing "stories in California and evacuations of 1,200 people; there were no noxious or toxic gases, but you still had to evacuate 1,200 people." (Wallkill Valley Times)
more than a gigawatt of new load requests that have come into the NYISO queue
you could get by without having a moratorium, that whatever is coming from the state can still be implemented ahead of any project of being approved, including ours
Montgomery is the clearest local example of the escalation a moratorium can become: a pause adopted to "buy time" while the state studied safety hardened into a permanent zoning prohibition, blocking a 169 MW project. The developers' own warning at the hearing — that local bans invite a state takeover of siting — is the ORES-for-storage argument stated from the industry side; at 169 MW the project would clear the 25 MW threshold that would put it under state siting, if standalone storage were ever brought into that forum. The case also shows the recurring fire-safety fault line: the developer and a peer firm citing national standards and load growth, against a board that judged its emergency services unready.
These marks record whether we opened the document behind the link — not how good the source is. How we verify.