BACKYARD NY / PROJECT REGISTRY
REC #004 · STATUS: ✕ KILLED — BANNED
✕Killed

Key Capture Energy BESS — Town of Montgomery

a.k.a. KCE NY 2

A 169 MW battery proposal the Town of Montgomery blocked by escalating from a one-year moratorium to a permanent zoning ban on battery storage.

IMG · GOOGLE PLACES Town of Montgomery · Orange County
Sector
ENERGY-STORAGE
Location
NORTH OF ROUTE 17K, BETWEEN STONE CASTLE ROAD AND BROWNS ROAD · TOWN OF MONTGOMERY · ORANGE COUNTY · HUDSON VALLEY
Developer
KEY CAPTURE ENERGY (ALBANY, NY), VIA PROJECT COMPANY KCE NY 2, LLC [fact sheet ›]
Capacity
169 MW
Process
MORATORIUM BANA local pause (moratorium) on new projects while rules are studied — or an outright ban. · LOCAL ZONINGLocal zoning — town/village land-use rules and special-use permits. Standalone battery storage is sited locally under home rule. · PILOT IDAPILOT / IDA — a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes agreement granted through an Industrial Development Agency.
Local law
Montgomery BESS Zoning Ban › — prohibited this project
Source confidence
MEDIUM-HIGHmedium-high. Confirmed by reading the sources: KCE NY 2 (169 MW) on an 8.03-acre site north of 17K between Stone Castle and Browns Road, aired at the Montgomery IDA hearing of Nov 9 2022, and carried on the IDA's project page as 'KCE NY 2, LLC' — where its status still reads **Pending** and the file set runs through an April 2023 hearing transcript, so IDA review continued past 2022. Every quotation in the support and opposition lists was checked verbatim against the article or minutes cited. The moratorium (12 months, Nov 28 2023) and the ban (special meeting Feb 25 2025, after a Feb 19 hearing) are both established by the reporting. **RESOLVED 2026-07-28, and the suspicion recorded here was correct.** The eCode360 chapter was opened for the first time (a bot-UA request served it where every earlier method 403'd), and the **March 5, 2025 effective date does not belong to this law at all** — the chapter attaches 3-5-2025 to *L.L. No. 3-2025*, which amends the definitions section and creates a Business Park Floating Zone, and 3-5-2025 is also the codification's own currency date. The ban is **L.L. No. 2-2025**, adopted 2-25-2025, and the chapter states no effective date for it. The **scope** is now settled too: § 235-9.1I prohibits BESS '[i]n all districts' except those authorized by the 2020 NYS Residential Code § 1206 for one- and two-family homes — no kWh or MW threshold. The same law repealed § 235-11.13. Still gated: the filed law text and the Table of Use Regulations attachment. Also unconfirmed: the statement that KCE NY 11 was 'withdrawn from the NYISO queue in 2019', which appears in no source located. Open: KCE NY 2's MWh/duration, and its formal disposition.
169 MW
Capacity

Background

Town of Montgomery · Orange County · Energy storage · Status: killed (zoning ban)

The project

KCE NY 2 was a 169-megawatt battery storage project from Key Capture Energy, proposed on an 8.03-acre site north of Route 17K between Stone Castle Road and Browns Road. It was aired at a Montgomery Industrial Development Agency public hearing in November 2022 and is recorded as "KCE NY 2, LLC" on the IDA's project page. (Wallkill Valley Times; Montgomery IDA) (A separate, earlier Key Capture project — KCE NY 11, a 20 MW battery also in the Town of Montgomery — received a NYSERDA energy-storage incentive; it is not the project at issue here. The company's announcement is explicit that a different project came first: "our KCE NY 1 project was the first project to be awarded under NYSERDA's energy storage incentive program." The announcement carries no date.) (Key Capture Energy)

The sequence

  1. Moratorium (Nov 28, 2023): the Town Board adopted a 12-month moratorium on battery storage — extended from an initial six months to align with Governor Hochul's statewide BESS safety study. (Wallkill Valley Times)
  2. Ban (Feb 25, 2025): after a public hearing on February 19, the board voted at a special meeting to amend its zoning to prohibit battery storage, acting on former Councilwoman Kristen Brown's 2023 proposal. The reporting describes the board banning battery storage "from town zoning completely for the time being," and both members quoted said the town could revisit it — Melick, "It's something we can always relook at during a later date"; Brescia, "if there are new innovations down the road and safety measures implemented, we can always reconsider revisiting this." (Wallkill Valley Times)

The ban would block KCE NY 2; no separate withdrawal is on record, and the Montgomery IDA still carries the project as Pending. (Montgomery IDA)

The law's number, effective date and exact scope are not established by anything opened here — the eCode360 amendment history that would settle them refuses automated and browser-style requests alike. This page therefore states what the reporting establishes and no more; the open questions are recorded in the case's watch list.

Support and opposition

At the February 2025 hearing, Key Capture Energy's Mike Carella pointed to "unprecedented load growth" in the lower Hudson Valley, and two Cypress Creek Renewables developers spoke — Will O'Leary warning that local bans could prompt the state to take over permitting, and Eva Raczkowski arguing incidents are rare under national fire-safety standards. The board was unmoved. Councilwoman Sheryl Melick said "there are too many unknowns about these battery storages, and I don't believe our fire departments are up to code with them." Supervisor Steve Brescia concurred, citing "stories in California and evacuations of 1,200 people; there were no noxious or toxic gases, but you still had to evacuate 1,200 people." (Wallkill Valley Times)

Chronology

Fire service∅None stated[Town of Montgomery (eCode360)]

For it

  • Mike Carella, Senior Manager of Development, Key Capture Energy — at the Feb 2025 ban hearing cited 'unprecedented load growth that we're seeing' and , the majority downstate and in the lower Hudson Valley [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Developer
    more than a gigawatt of new load requests that have come into the NYISO queue
  • Mike Carella, Key Capture Energy — argued against the 2023 moratorium too, telling the board , and offering annual training with the Coldenham Fire Department; the minutes record a PILOT before the IDA worth $3 million to the town and school district plus $1.5 million through a host community agreement [Town of Montgomery (eCode360)]
    Developer
    you could get by without having a moratorium, that whatever is coming from the state can still be implemented ahead of any project of being approved, including ours
  • Will O'Leary, Senior Project Developer, Cypress Creek Renewables — warned a local ban could push the state to bring battery-storage permitting under state control [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Business
  • Eva Raczkowski, Project Developer, Cypress Creek Renewables — argued incidents are rare and facilities are designed and monitored to strict national fire-safety standards [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Business

Against it

  • Kristen Brown, former Town Councilwoman — originated the ban proposal (Sept 2023), citing battery-fire danger and strain on first responders [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Official
  • Supervisor Steve Brescia — 'I concur with Councilwoman Melick, there's just too many unknowns out there. I've read stories in California and evacuations of 1,200 people; there were no noxious or toxic gases, but you still had to evacuate 1,200 people... But if there are new innovations down the road and safety measures implemented, we can always reconsider revisiting this' [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Official
  • Councilwoman Sheryl Melick — 'I don't believe our fire departments are up to code with them... I just think it's hazardous for the residents of the town' [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Official
  • Resident Don Berger (2023 moratorium hearing) — backed a full year: 'we certainly at this point have very limited knowledge of the negative aspects of this thing... I don't believe you'll have the answer to that in six months' [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Resident
  • Elizabeth Case, Walden resident — objected at the Nov 2022 IDA hearing to the project's tax abatement: 'I'm just thinking that they need to pay their fair share. I pay my fair share, and everybody else in the room who are residents of the Town of Montgomery pay their fair share' [Wallkill Valley Times / My Hudson Valley]
    Resident
  • Matthew Hunt, Chief of the Coldenham Fire District — submitted written correspondence that Councilwoman Brown read into the Nov 28, 2023 moratorium hearing; the minutes record that it was read and filed but do not reproduce or characterize it [Town of Montgomery (eCode360)]
    Fire service

Context — not for or against

Analysis

Montgomery is the clearest local example of the escalation a moratorium can become: a pause adopted to "buy time" while the state studied safety hardened into a permanent zoning prohibition, blocking a 169 MW project. The developers' own warning at the hearing — that local bans invite a state takeover of siting — is the ORES-for-storage argument stated from the industry side; at 169 MW the project would clear the 25 MW threshold that would put it under state siting, if standalone storage were ever brought into that forum. The case also shows the recurring fire-safety fault line: the developer and a peer firm citing national standards and load growth, against a board that judged its emergency services unready.

Sources

These marks record whether we opened the document behind the link — not how good the source is. How we verify.

// every field traceable to a primary source · outcome classified per documented record · BACKYARD NY