A 12 MW battery that actually got built and energized in Orange County in 2023 — and then became the region's cautionary fire story.
Warwick · Orange County · Energy storage · Status: delivered — built and energized in 2023; the Church Street unit condemned and disconnected after the December 2025 fire
Unlike the proposals elsewhere on this site, the Warwick system was sited, approved, and energized. Convergent Energy + Power, working with utility Orange & Rockland, built three 4 MW battery systems (12 MW / 57 MWh total) — two on Warwick Valley Central School District property and one at 28 Church Street in the Village — and brought them online on May 15, 2023. The Village of Warwick Planning Board had approved the Church Street site plan back in December 2020. (Orange & Rockland; Convergent)
It is a non-wires alternative — "the first non-wires alternative project of its kind in Orange County." Through a competitive bid, O&R selected Convergent "to cost-effectively increase capacity at its Wisner substation in Warwick," letting the utility "delay building costly new infrastructure that is designed to accommodate energy use at its peak — an event that occurs only a few times during the year." It serves 7,500 customers across the Town and Village of Warwick and parts of Florida, Greenwood Lake and Pine Island. (Orange & Rockland)
The same site became the region's cautionary tale. Fire alarms activated at two of the systems on the evening of June 26, 2023, weeks after they came online and amid heavy storms; a fire started at one of the two the following day. Convergent took the unusual step of naming the equipment — Powin Energy's "Centipede" containerised system — saying it "does not have this model deployed anywhere else" and that "the Powin Centipedes are the only systems that are currently experiencing problems." No cause was published at the time; Powin's team was "assessing the source of the problem." (Energy-Storage.news)
The second fire came on December 19, 2025, at 28 Church Street. Convergent's own statement that night described a fire "localized in one of the containers," no injuries, no spread to adjacent containers, and continuous air monitoring by Orange County HazMat showing "no alarm levels." (Convergent, via the Village)
The Village's account is sharper. In a statement of December 31, 2025, Mayor Michael Newhard wrote that the Building Department "has issued a Notice of Violation and Condemnation Order," that Village counsel's letter to Convergent "addresses the unauthorized activation of the system," and that "Convergent does not currently hold a Certificate of Compliance due to its failure to comply with enhanced safety monitoring requirements and should not have been operational." He added that after the 2023 incidents the Village Board and Village Engineer had requested additional safety monitoring, "which was dismissed by both the battery manufacturer and Convergent." The system was "disconnected from the power grid, internally disengaged, and tarped." (Village of Warwick)
What followed is on the same page. The Village retained an independent engineer, LaBella Associates, whose April 2026 environmental assessment found that soil and groundwater data "do not indicate that there were any adverse impacts to the environment resulting from the battery fires at the site." At a March 9, 2026 meeting, NYSERDA told the Village that the root-cause analysis of the 2023 fire "was determined to have been caused by water infiltration," that Convergent "has been suspended from undertaking any new work in New York State for 90 days" pending review of the 2025 analysis, and that Powin "has since declared bankruptcy." NYSERDA also said the project "was not a NYSERDA-authorized project" and that when it was installed "there were no statewide regulatory guidelines or oversight requirements in place for this type of facility" — the January 2026 regulations that now exist are not retroactive. The root cause of the December 2025 fire remains unpublished. (Village of Warwick)
That December fire became the rallying point for a fresh wave of municipal moratoria across the Hudson Valley (see the landscape overview). The full fire record — both incidents, the emergency response, and what a lithium-ion storage fire actually involves — is laid out in the Warwick fire explainer.
opens the door to a more sustainable energy future for our customers
critical to a more sustainable, cost-effective and reliable electric grid
addresses the unauthorized activation of the system,
the Village Board and Village Engineer requested additional safety monitoring, which was dismissed by both the battery manufacturer and Convergent
Warwick is the counter-example the rest of the inventory needs — proof that ordinary local site-plan review can produce a built, operating BESS — but it is not a clean one, and presenting it as such would be dishonest. The project both demonstrates the process working and supplies the fire-and-compliance story that hardened opposition to projects like Terra-Gen/Alcazar and the Saugerties proposal. The detail opponents and defenders read differently is the "unauthorized system" framing: if the December 2025 unit was operating out of compliance, the case for enforced standards over blanket prohibition is stronger — but the recurrence of fire at a single Hudson Valley site is exactly what local boards cite. The state's own account, as the Village records it, complicates both readings: there were no statewide oversight requirements when this system was installed, the rules that now exist do not reach it, and the safety monitoring the Village asked for after 2023 was declined by the parties who would have performed it. Whether that is an argument for standards or against siting depends on whether one expects the standards to be enforced.
These marks record whether we opened the document behind the link — not how good the source is. How we verify.